The Institution
Ellie's Sūpu-Shō (エリー・スープ賞) operates as an elite, independent collective dedicated to the rigorous appraisal, certification, and elevation of exceptional soups served within local culinary establishments.
Conveying the utmost seriousness and prestige, our anonymous inspectors evaluate regional creations without bias, providing culinary institutions with definitive ribbon honors that signify absolute excellence to patrons worldwide.
The Criteria
Every ladleful undergoes evaluation under three unchanging pillars:
-
Soup Flavor
Depth, clarity, extraction precision, and foundational broth execution.
-
Novel Ingredients
The calculated incorporation of unconventional, creative elements.
-
Harmony of Mouthfeel
Viscosity, texture cohesion, temperature, and structural tactile flow.
Recent Appraisals & Awards
Flavor: 10.0 |
Novelty: 9.5 |
Mouthfeel: 10.0
"An absolute masterclass in coastal culinary arts. The rich, buttery depth of local San Diego sea urchin is folded into a 48-hour white miso broth, smoked gently over applewood. The novel integration of finger lime caviar provides bursts of acidity that slice through the unctuous density, achieving a sublime harmony of mouthfeel that lingers long after the final spoonful."
Flavor: 9.0 |
Novelty: 8.5 |
Mouthfeel: 9.0
"This crystal-clear consommé exhibits exceptional technical execution. The broth carries the deep, sweet molasses notes of fermented black garlic, perfectly anchoring the earthy, apricot-like aroma of wild chanterelles foraged from the rural Ohio woodlands. It meets our standards perfectly, presenting a velvety, perfectly clean mouthfeel with zero sediment."
Flavor: 8.0 |
Novelty: 9.0 |
Mouthfeel: 7.5
"An ambitious dish that pairs rich, shredded duck confit with a sharp, vibrant broth infused with dried hibiscus petals and guajillo chilies. While the flavor profile is exceptionally bold and the use of hibiscus is a brilliant novel touch, the mouthfeel falls just short of expectations due to an excess of duck fat that wasn't fully skimmed, slightly masking the brightness of the broth."
Request Judicial Examination
Jurisdiction Requirement: To be eligible for professional judging, restaurants must operate within the greater San Diego, California or Gambier, Ohio municipal regions.